Compare Service Quotes

Enter the details from maintenance contract proposals you have received and compare them side by side. This tool runs entirely in your browser -- no data is submitted or stored. Think of it as a procurement worksheet that does the math for you and flags the terms that matter most.

How to Evaluate an Elevator Maintenance Contract

An elevator maintenance contract is one of the largest recurring operating expenses in any multi-story building, and it is also one of the most commonly misunderstood. Building owners routinely sign agreements based on the monthly price alone, only to discover years later that they have been paying for minimal coverage with aggressive lock-in terms. What follows is a straightforward breakdown of what to look for, what to avoid, and how to tell a good contract from one that is designed to benefit the vendor at your expense.

The Three Contract Types

Oil & Grease (O&G): The cheapest option on paper, and the most expensive in practice for any building with equipment older than 10 years. The vendor lubricates and adjusts components on a scheduled basis. Every part, every repair, every callback is billed separately. You are essentially paying for preventive visits and nothing else. If you have new equipment under the manufacturer warranty, O&G can make sense. For everything else, it is a gamble.

Full Maintenance: Covers parts and labor for normal wear and tear in addition to the routine maintenance visits. This is the standard contract type for most commercial buildings. The critical distinction is what counts as "normal wear" versus what the vendor classifies as an exclusion. Read the exclusion list before anything else in the contract.

All-Inclusive: The broadest coverage tier. Typically includes everything in a full maintenance contract plus items that are normally excluded: cab interiors, door panels, fixtures, and sometimes even code-mandated upgrades. The monthly cost is higher, but your exposure to surprise bills is significantly lower. For older equipment or buildings with high traffic, this is usually the most predictable option from a budgeting standpoint.

What Makes a Good Contract

• A clear, specific list of what is covered -- not vague language like "standard maintenance items"
• A defined response time guarantee with a meaningful remedy if the vendor misses it
• An escalation clause tied to a published index (CPI) rather than an arbitrary fixed percentage
• A reasonable term length (1-3 years) with a 30-60 day cancellation notice window
• No auto-renewal for more than one year, and written notice of renewal at least 90 days in advance
• Named technicians or a defined service territory, not a promise to "dispatch the next available tech"
• Transparent parts sourcing -- the vendor should use OEM or equivalent parts, not salvaged components

Common Traps

The lowball and lock: An aggressively low monthly price paired with a 5-year term and a 90+ day cancellation notice. The vendor operates at a thin margin for the first year, then applies a 5-7% annual escalation. By year three, you are paying market rate. By year five, you are overpaying. And the exit clause makes it difficult to leave without paying a penalty or waiting out the full term.

Vague exclusions: Contracts that say "acts of God, misuse, vandalism, and items not considered normal wear" without defining what qualifies. This gives the vendor wide latitude to deny coverage on any repair they choose. Insist on specific, named exclusions -- if they will not list them, that tells you something.

The parts markup game: On O&G contracts, parts are billed at whatever the vendor charges. Some vendors apply a 200-400% markup on parts. Ask for the parts pricing schedule or a "cost plus" arrangement before signing.

Evergreen auto-renewals: The contract renews automatically for another full term (not month-to-month) unless you send written cancellation within a narrow window, sometimes only 30 days. Miss that window by a week and you are locked in for another 3-5 years.

Response time without teeth: A guaranteed 2-hour response time sounds great until you read the fine print and realize "response" means a phone call, not a technician on-site. And the guarantee only applies during business hours, Monday through Friday. Clarify what "response" means and whether the guarantee includes weekends, holidays, and after-hours calls.

Your Negotiating Position

You have more bargaining power than you think, especially if you manage multiple elevators or multiple buildings. Vendors operate on thin margins in competitive markets and are willing to negotiate on term length, escalation caps, and cancellation windows if it means winning the contract. The fact that you are comparing quotes and asking detailed questions already signals that you are not going to sign the first proposal that comes across your desk. That alone changes the dynamic.

Get everything in writing. Verbal promises from a sales representative do not survive the first disputed repair bill. If the rep says "we would cover that," ask them to add it to the contract language. If they will not, treat the verbal promise as nonexistent.